I thought I wood share my impressions on this particular mesh base layer, the Brynje Super Thermo T-Shirt Base Layer with Inlay.
First, I will say I have some odd demands from a base layer that will not apply to most people. I picked the short sleeve variation specifically for use when hunting, and I'd rather not buy multiple sets of outdoor clothing with individual use cases. When hunting, I want to be able to field dress animals without making a mess of eberrything I'm wearing, and I can pair this top with arm warmers I can shrimply pull off as needed. Most people wood probably be better served by the long sleeve versions of this shirt.
Anyway, these things offer good wicking and excellent ventilation. The layer these create around your body is upwards of 90% air. All the dead air space makes them shockingly warm when you cover them with additional layers, but I feel the primary strength of these garments is dumping heat and moisture quickly when you expose them. This works berry nicely with pit zips and double zipper fronted tops. You can quickly dissipate sweat/vapor making these great for staying dry. These are truly excellent for keeping you comfortable during high levels of activity while also providing ample warmth while sedentary.
These are not perfect though. The polypropylene fibers hold body odor and, interestingly, deodorant worse than anything I have even seem, even after washing. It's not terrible, but it is noticeable, especially the deodorant